Revision history [back]

Hi,

The error means that your opencl compiler could not compile some code and quit compiling.

I also had a problem trying to get run the face detection on Mac OS X. But I solved it! Here's how:

finding out the erroneous opencl kernel file:

modules/ocl/src/initialization.cpp tries to compile opencl kernels. unfortunately the ATI/AMD compiler on the mac does not compile opencl kernel. This is what causes the error. To find out which kernel it it I inserted at the beginning of the method

      cl_kernel openCLGetKernelFromSource(const Context *clCxt, const char **source, string kernelName,
                                        const char *build_options)

the following line:

      fprintf(stderr, "Loading %s %s\n", clCxt->impl->binpath.c_str(), kernelName.c_str());

now I can see all kernels that are compiled. The last one before the error causes the crash. I my case it was "integral_cols". A short "grep" command later I knew it was in "modules/ocl/src/opencl/imgproc_integral.cl"

finding and fixing the erroneous line:

This was a bit of trial and error. I took a program which only compiles opencl kernels. (In my case it was my Qt based test program for openCL), but you may use opencv itself. In that case you always have to patch - make opencl - make install for each iteration which is not nice after all...

By commenting out all code with "#if 0" ... "#endif" blocks and slowly de-commenting I deduced which lines did not work. In my case it was some combination of the conditional-operator ("?: operator") and double braces "[][]" in one statement which could not be compiled. I refactored this code. You can see the result here: (the #if 0 block is what not compiled, and the #else branch is my version)

#if 0
        sum_t[0] = (i == 0 ? 0 : lm_sum[0][LSIZE_2 + LOG_LSIZE]);
        sqsum_t[0] = (i == 0 ? 0 : lm_sqsum[0][LSIZE_2 + LOG_LSIZE]);
        sum_t[1] =  (i == 0 ? 0 : lm_sum[1][LSIZE_2 + LOG_LSIZE]);
    sqsum_t[1] =  (i == 0 ? 0 : lm_sqsum[1][LSIZE_2 + LOG_LSIZE]);
 #else
        if (i==0) {
            sum_t[0] = 0;
            sqsum_t[0] = 0;
            sum_t[1] =  0;
            sqsum_t[1] =  0;
        } else {
            sum_t[0] = lm_sum[0][LSIZE_2 + LOG_LSIZE];
            sqsum_t[0] = lm_sqsum[0][LSIZE_2 + LOG_LSIZE];
            sum_t[1] =  lm_sum[1][LSIZE_2 + LOG_LSIZE];
            sqsum_t[1] =  lm_sqsum[1][LSIZE_2 + LOG_LSIZE];
        }
 #endif

the integral_rows kernel had a similar problem and was to be fixed also:

#if 0
        src_t[0] = i + lid < rows ? srcsum[(lid+i) * src_step + gid * 2] : 0;
        sqsrc_t[0] = i + lid < rows ? srcsqsum[(lid+i) * src_step + gid * 2] : 0;
        src_t[1] = i + lid < rows ? srcsum[(lid+i) * src_step + gid * 2 + 1] : 0;
        sqsrc_t[1] = i + lid < rows ? srcsqsum[(lid+i) * src_step + gid * 2 + 1] : 0;

        sum_t[0] =  (i == 0 ? 0 : lm_sum[0][LSIZE_2 + LOG_LSIZE]);
        sqsum_t[0] =  (i == 0 ? 0 : lm_sqsum[0][LSIZE_2 + LOG_LSIZE]);
        sum_t[1] =  (i == 0 ? 0 : lm_sum[1][LSIZE_2 + LOG_LSIZE]);
        sqsum_t[1] =  (i == 0 ? 0 : lm_sqsum[1][LSIZE_2 + LOG_LSIZE]);
#else
        if (i + lid < rows) {
            src_t[0] =  srcsum[(lid+i) * src_step + gid * 2];
            sqsrc_t[0] = srcsqsum[(lid+i) * src_step + gid * 2];
            src_t[1] = srcsum[(lid+i) * src_step + gid * 2 + 1] ;
            sqsrc_t[1] = srcsqsum[(lid+i) * src_step + gid * 2 + 1];
        } else {
            src_t[0] =  0;
            sqsrc_t[0] =  0;
            src_t[1] =  0;
            sqsrc_t[1] =  0;
        }

        if (i==0) {
            sum_t[0] = 0;
            sqsum_t[0] = 0;
            sum_t[1] =  0;
            sqsum_t[1] =  0;
        } else {
            sum_t[0] = lm_sum[0][LSIZE_2 + LOG_LSIZE];
            sqsum_t[0] = lm_sqsum[0][LSIZE_2 + LOG_LSIZE];
            sum_t[1] =  lm_sum[1][LSIZE_2 + LOG_LSIZE];
            sqsum_t[1] =  lm_sqsum[1][LSIZE_2 + LOG_LSIZE];
        }
#endif

after the fix I rebuild and re-installed opencv and, viola, I had a working face detection.

I hope that you can hunt down and problem in whatever kernel as well to get the function that you want to get run. For debugging, C/C++ knowledge should help you. The part in the kernel that does break it is hopefully just some calculation like in my case.

Best Regards, Ralf.

Hi,